DFP Header Area

Match Pages - Match Information

Full time

Edinburgh Rugby

Edinburgh Rugby

17 - 26

3 - 12

Munster Rugby

Munster Rugby
  • 13th January 2013
  • KO: 12:45
  • Scottish Gas Murrayfield , Edinburgh
  • Att: 6,220
  • Referee: Greg Garner
  • Heineken Cup

Current standing

Match Pages - Current Standing

4
Edinburgh
2
Munster

Positions at 20 Jan 2013

Head to head

Match Pages - Head to Head

Edinburgh Rugby
Munster Rugby
1 Wins 4
4 Losses 1
0 Draws 0

Last time

Match Pages - Last Time

13 - 17
30th Mar 2019

Recent form

Match Pages - Form Guide

L
L
L
L
L
W
W
L

Season so far

Match Page - Season so far

Tries

0

Edinburgh Rugby

0

Munster Rugby

Metres Gained

0

Edinburgh Rugby

0

Munster Rugby

Passes Completed

0

Edinburgh Rugby

0

Munster Rugby

Tackles Made

0

Edinburgh Rugby

0

Munster Rugby

Penalties Conceded

0

Edinburgh Rugby

0

Munster Rugby

A Case of Win or Bust

January 13, 2013 12:00 am By Munster Rugby

A Case of Win or Bust

With Saracens pulling off a come from behind win against an ill disciplined Racing Metro in Nantes yesterday, Munster know exactly what they must do this afternoon in Murrayfield.

Going into yesterday’s games, there was the possibility that they could top their Pool One if the won their remaining games starting today in Edinburgh. But now in all probability they’ll have to fight for a best runner up spot along with several others.

Saracens are on 18 points with a home game to come against Munster’s opponents this afternoon and the English club are now a very short order with the bookies to close the deal next weekend.

The snow that’s falling in the Scottish capital this morning is not likely to have much affect on proceedings except perhaps to force the introduction of an orange coloured ball. And the home with nothing to play for other than pride can be counted on to give more than a good account of themselves and their supporters who may in fact be matched in numbers by Munster folk who have descended on the city in their droves.

Four points is a must but not a gimme in the most important game of Munster’s season.

Munster: F Jones; D Howlett capt, K Earls, J Downey, S Zebo; R O'Gara, C Murray; D Kilcoyne, D Varley, BJ Botha; D O'Callaghan, D Ryan; P O'Mahony, T O'Donnell, J Coughlan. Replacements: M Sherry, W du Preez, J Ryan, B Holland, P Butler, D Williams, I Keatley, C Laulala.

Edinburgh Rugby: Greig Tonks; Dougie Fife, Ben Cairns, Matt Scott, Tim Visser; Greig Laidlaw capt, Richie Rees; Allan Jacobsen, Steven Lawrie, Willem Nel; Grant Gilchrist, Sean Cox; Stuart McInally, Dimitri Basilaia, David Denton. Replacements: Andy Titterrell, Robin Hislop, Geoff Cross, Netani Talei, Roddy Grant, Piers Francis, Ben Atiga, Sep Visser

Munster - Match Page - Lineups - Preview

Line-ups

Edinburgh Rugby
Pos  
15

Greig Tonks

14

Dougie Fife

13

Ben Cairns

12

Matt Scott

11

Tim Visser

10

Greig Laidlaw

9

Richie Rees

1

Robin Hislop

2

Steven Lawrie

3

WP Nel

4

Grant Gilchrist

5

Sean Cox

6

Stuart McInally

7

Dimitri Basilaia

8

David Denton

Replacements
16

Andy Titterrell

17

Alex Allan

18

Geoff Cross

19

Netani Talei

20

Roddy Grant

21

Piers Francis

22

Ben Atiga

23

Sep Visser

Munster Rugby
Pos  
15 Felix Jones
14 Doug Howlett
13 Keith Earls
12 James Downey
11 Simon Zebo
10 Ronan O'Gara
9 Conor Murray
1 Dave Kilcoyne
2 Damien Varley
3 BJ Botha
4 Donncha O'Callaghan
5 Donnacha Ryan
6 Peter O'Mahony
7 Tommy O'Donnell
8 James Coughlan
Replacements
16 Sean Henry
17 Wian Du Preez
18 John Ryan
19 Billy Holland
20 Paddy Butler
21 Duncan Williams
22 Ian Keatley
23 Casey Laulala

Munster Win In Murrayfield

January 13, 2013 12:00 am By Munster Rugby

Munster Win In Murrayfield

Munster kept their play off hopes alive with a 26-17 victory over Edinburgh at Murrayfield in front of a largely Munster crowd.

It was a win that leaves them in contention for one of the 'best runner-up' places and a possible trip to Harlequins or Clermont but they really need to do next weekend what they failed to do in Edinburgh, win with a bonus point.

They set out by giving themselves the cushion of a lead and led 12-3 at half time but it was the minutes before the break that probably decided their fate.

Camped on the Edinburgh line they probed left and right but were denied and then when awarded a penalty Keith Earls tapped and went but was whistled back because according to referee Greg Gardiner he hadn't given the mark. Mind you later on when Grieg Laidlaw took a quick tap without been given the mark, it ended in a yellow card for Dave Kilcoyne.

Ronan O’Gara opened Munster’s account with an early penalty but Munster put themselves under pressure when an overthrow at a five metre line out followed by a knock on gave Edinburgh a foothold metres from the Munster line.

Superb defence kept the home side at bay and when the siege was lifted Munster went downfield for O’Gara to kick two penalties in the 25th and 29th minutes.

Laidlaw pulled one back three minutes later, a blatant forward pass in the lead-up going unnoticed, but once again when Edinburgh were penalised at scrum time O’Gara landed his fourth successful kick for a nine point interval lead.

Munster were reduced to 14 when Dave Kilcoyne was yellow carded in the 48th minute but they still managed to win a penalty try from a scrum after Grieg Laidlaw was sent to the bin five minutes later.

The outcome was put beyond all doubt when Conor Murray scored his side’s second try in the 61st minute though before that Dougie Fife escaped sanction after deliberately knocking on a try scoring pass from Earls to Simon Zebo.

In the closing stages Munster ran out of gas and Fife ran in a brace of tries which if nothing else served to highlight the wisdom of Munster's early tactics.

Munster: F Jones; D Howlett capt, K Earls, J Downey (C Laulala 62nd min), S Zebo; R O'Gara (I Keatley 64th min), C Murray (D Williams 69th min); D Kilcoyne, D Varley, BJ Botha; D O'Callaghan (B Holland 69th min), D Ryan; P O'Mahony, T O'Donnell, J Coughlan (Wian du Preez 51-59th min, P Butler 64th min). Replacements not used: J Ryan.

Match Pages - Summary

Edinburgh Rugby

Tries

Fife 71' , 76'

Conversions

Laidlaw 72' , 77'

Penalties

Laidlaw 32'

Yellow Cards

Laidlaw 53

Munster Rugby

Tries

Murray 61'

Conversions

O'Gara 54' , 62'

Penalties

O'Gara 2' , 25' , 29' , 35'

Penalty Tries

63'

Yellow Cards

Kilcoyne 48

Match Page - Timeline

17 - 26

Conversion 77'

G. Laidlaw

15 - 26

Try 76'

D. Fife

10 - 26

Conversion 72'

G. Laidlaw

8 - 26

Try 71'

D. Fife

-

Replacement 69'

C. Murray

D. Williams

-

Replacement 69'

D. O'Callaghan

B. Holland

-

Replacement 69'

G. Gilchrist

N. Talei

-

Replacement 69'

W. Nel

G. Cross

-

Replacement 69'

R. Hislop

A. Allan

-

Replacement 64'

J. Coughlan

P. Butler

-

Replacement 64'

R. O'Gara

I. Keatley

-

Replacement 63'

J. Downey

C. Laulala

3 - 17

Pentry 63'

.

3 - 26

Conversion 62'

R. O'Gara

3 - 24

Try 61'

C. Murray

-

Replacement 58'

W. du Preez

J. Coughlan

-

Replacement 54'

B. Cairns

B. Atiga

3 - 19

Conversion 54'

R. O'Gara

-

Yellow Card 53'

G. Laidlaw

-

Replacement 50'

J. Coughlan

W. du Preez

-

Yellow Card 48'

D. Kilcoyne

-

Replacement 48'

S. Lawrie

A. Titterrell

-

Replacement 41'

D. Basilaia

R. Grant

3 - 12

Penalty 35'

R. O'Gara

3 - 9

Penalty 32'

G. Laidlaw

0 - 9

Penalty 29'

R. O'Gara

0 - 6

Penalty 25'

R. O'Gara

-

Missed Penalty 17'

R. O'Gara

0 - 3

Penalty 2'

R. O'Gara

Match page - Match Stats

No statistics available

Match Page - Lineups

  • M - Metres Gained
  • C - Carries
  • P - Passes made
  • T - Tackles
  • TO - Turnovers Won
Edinburgh Rugby
Pos   T D C P
15

Greig Tonks

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
14

Dougie Fife

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
2
13

Ben Cairns

Replacement: Ben Atiga (54)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
12

Matt Scott

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
11

Tim Visser

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
10

Greig Laidlaw

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
2 1
9

Richie Rees

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
1

Robin Hislop

Replacement: Alex Allan (70)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
2

Steven Lawrie

Replacement: Andy Titterrell (48)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
3

WP Nel

Replacement: Geoff Cross (70)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
4

Grant Gilchrist

Replacement: Netani Talei (69) Replacement: Netani Talei (70)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
5

Sean Cox

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
6

Stuart McInally

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
7

Dimitri Basilaia

Replacement: Roddy Grant (41)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
8

David Denton

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
replacements
16

Andy Titterrell

Replaced Steven Lawrie (48)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
17

Alex Allan

Replaced Robin Hislop (70)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
18

Geoff Cross

Replaced WP Nel (70)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
19

Netani Talei

Replaced Grant Gilchrist (69) Replaced Grant Gilchrist (70)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
20

Roddy Grant

Replaced Dimitri Basilaia (41)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
21

Piers Francis

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
22

Ben Atiga

Replaced Ben Cairns (54)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
23

Sep Visser

  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
Munster Rugby
Pos   T D C P
15 Felix Jones
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
14 Doug Howlett
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
13 Keith Earls
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
12 James Downey
Replacement: Casey Laulala (63)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
11 Simon Zebo
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
10 Ronan O'Gara
Replacement: Ian Keatley (64)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
2 4
9 Conor Murray
Replacement: Duncan Williams (69)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
1
1
Dave Kilcoyne
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
2 Damien Varley
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
3 BJ Botha
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
4 Donncha O'Callaghan
Replacement: Billy Holland (69)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
5 Donnacha Ryan
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
6 Peter O'Mahony
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
7 Tommy O'Donnell
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
8 James Coughlan
Replacement: Wian Du Preez (50)
Replacement: Paddy Butler (64)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
replacements
16 Sean Henry
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
17 Wian Du Preez
Replaced: James Coughlan (50)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
18 John Ryan
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
19 Billy Holland
Replaced: Donncha O'Callaghan (69)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
20 Paddy Butler
Replaced: James Coughlan (64)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
21 Duncan Williams
Replaced: Conor Murray (69)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
22 Ian Keatley
Replaced: Ronan O'Gara (64)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
23 Casey Laulala
Replaced: James Downey (63)
  • M:
  • C:
  • P:
  • T:
  • TO:
X